Tuesday, 11 November 2014

NAM LE FAULKNER

Nam Le and William Faulkner both believe that writers have a responsibility to uphold universal truths and humanity through their work. Do you agree that writers have an obligation to do this?


  Nam Le's story, Love and Honour and Pity and Pride and Compassion and Sacrifice, is an example of writing that is "worth writing about, worth the agony and the sweat" according to the idea presented by William Faulkner in his banquet speech. Faulkner claimed in his speech that it is a privilege for a write "to help man endure be lifting his heart, by reminding him of the courage and the honor and hope and pride and compassion and pity and sacrifice". Furthermore, if a writer forgets about the universal verities, then his writing is considered "ephemeral and doomed".

  By adopting that Faulkner's idea into his story's title, Nam Le is admitting that it is a writer's obligation to represent man kind with universal truths and humanity. In the story, Nam Le reveals the process of him unfolding his way through the perpetual struggles between him and his father. In the end, he unravels the truth about his identity as a man, being that he was born not very long after the Vietnamese war, and most importantly, how that affects the perspective he holds about himself, his father and his country. In one scene, after reading a script written by Nam, his father says to him "You want their pity"; in the end of the story, his father burns the script that Nam Le has written about the War. Instead of getting mad at his father as usual, Nam Le now understands the value of writing that he is responsible for: his writing should not be an excuse about "defeats in which nobody loses of values, of victories" but "of the props, the pillars to help him endure and prevail", as mentioned by Faulkner in his speech that is referred to at the top.

  Nevertheless, this idea of upholding these perpetual universal truths and verities seem to contradict the meaning of writing when it was first found by our ancestors since writing can be referred to as expression of language through letters or marks. Sumerian cuneiform is the first known writing form that dates back to 3300 BC. It simply contained symbols marked on clay and the expressions account a total of 1500 symbols themselves were limited. The writing was created to reflect their daily life activities, rituals events and warfare between different clans. Going even further back in time, stone men used to carved images of their tools, hunting animals and arcane symbols that represented their gods.*

 Personally, writing should be able to get across a message to the reader and that message does not necessary need to include a significant depth of meaning to it in order to be worthwhile. A description or reflection of one's life, an intriguing event, or as simple as an object can be considered worthwhile. Although by lacking meaning from its content can result in little effect on the reader, a descriptive piece of writing or simply a diary can still be considered 'good' writing given that fact that reflecting and describing was once all there ever was in writing. William Faulkner can call a piece of writing "ephemeral" judging on its content, however, it will be unfair if he calls it "doomed" because if that piece of writing contains a message that the writer wants to get across to his reader, then it is definitely worthwhile.

*Early Forms of Writing: Cuneiform
https://web.cn.edu/kwheeler/documents/Cuneiform.pdf



Friday, 3 October 2014

White Angel Reflection,

                                                       
                                                               Frisco's role as a Narrator


        In the short story 'White Angel', its theme evolves around the changes that happened in liberal society back in the sixties . The older brother, 'Carlton', represents the hippie-movement and the younger brother, 'Frisco', reflects on the changes as the result of this movement. With Frisco's innocence as a nine year-old, Michael Cunningham is able to reflect on the theme of sex, drugs and party along with the changes and consequences that follow.
       Frisco has that power of a simple-minded child whose life flows in the direction steered by someone influential, which makes it Carlton in this case. In the story, Frisco and Carlton are both on a journey towards an ideal life most desired by Carlton. Frisco depends on Carlton for his decisions because Carlton's ideas appeal to Frisco as something cool that will make him the same as everyone in the 'Woodstock Nation'. One of the change that Carlton imposes on his brother is drugs an booze. Drugs and booze were popular back then and Frisco's practice with them symbolizes the society, 'I was, thanks to Carlton, the most criminally advanced nine-year-old'.
       Too add more to the idea of the 'Woodstock Nation' hippie movement, Carlton poses a new way of living to Frisco in which he claims, 'Miracles are happening'. This life-style of Carlton includes one other aspect of life that had burst in the sixties society and it is sex. Sex was increasingly popular in the sixties as a consequence of high hope after the war. The moment when Frisco bumps into Carlton and his girlfriend in the graveyard making love sends message about the sort of things people would do in the society. Furthermore, the way Carlton 'winks' at Frisco after he sees Frisco spying on him conveys a sense of normality that does not fit with such situation. Consequently, Frisco gets shocked after what he witnesses,' My heart beats fast as a sparrow'. However, Frisco still manages to lie to his mother, as she senses that something is going on, to protect his Carlton. This lying action Frisco to his mother reflects how influential the hippie movement was in the society especially to the youth population.
       Lastly, the party that happens in the story explains what kind of music people listen to and what sort of activities people do in a party and as always, Frisco is the one who notices the changes amongst everyone because of Carlton's influence. During the dance in the party, Frisco notices how his mother dances to Carlton's music, 'My mother, who is known around school for Sicilian discipline, dances freely, which is news to everybody'. In one instant, Frisco in an effort to impress Carlton by commenting on the party says to Carlton and his girlfriend,'Shit, man'. This sort of language is not what one expects from a nine year-old boy. It might not be appropriate for a child to use that kind of language in today's world but back then, it was a normal thing to say for a child because the people surrounded him also used the same kind of language. Cunningham successfully reflects the liberal idea that spurted with Frisco as a narrator since as a nine year-old child, Frisco tries to copy his elder brother's idea.




Friday, 19 September 2014

english essay

Essay about Capote and his making of In Cold Blood

Truman Capote is a renowned author with many successes, one of which is the first self-claimed non-fiction novel ‘In Cold Blood’. It is not just the novel itself that is famous. The process of creating it is also famous, or rather infamous. The novel received a lot of critics from the press and the reader after evidences kept away intentionally by Capote got revealed to public. Capote is a deceiving author who is willing to sacrifice his readers and his subjects to achieve his goal. This contributes to defeat the purpose of a non-fiction novel.

In one Pati Hill's interview with Capote, a reporter working for The Paris Review, Capote mentioned that he writes his story in the most 'natural' way possible, "Finding the right form for your story is simply to realize the most natural way of telling the story...As an orange is final. As an orange is something nature has made just right"(Hill par.18). In order to be able to apply his perfect 'orange' ideology to his writing, Capote deliberately adjusts the storyline to his advantage. For example Al Dewey and his team did not respond right away after Floyd Wells's suspicion about Dick and Perry. The truth is Dewey waited for 5 days after starting to investigate Dick and Perry, because he believed that the murder(s) has got to be related to the Clutters. This alteration was done so that Capote has a hero in his story. Also, by giving this white lie about Dewey, Capote was able to get access to the documents of the investigation through Dewey himself. Capote understands that without Dewey’s incentive to share the case’s documents with him in the first place, he would never be able to complete his ‘orange’. However, it is evident that Capote successfully bought off Dewey and his wife. For example, in 1963, Capote took them to Beverley Hills to socialize with his friends, including Frank Sinatra and Natalie Wood. After all, Capote got what he wanted with Dewey by buying them off and with the book; he discards unimportant evidence so his ‘orange’ won’t have a distorted shape. However, in the end, Capote’s actions reject the claim about his 'immaculately factual' book because it is now immaculately Capote-made.

Through his interviews with his primary sources, Capote was able to make personal connection with them, especially with Perry Smith. The film based on how Capote created 'In Cold Blood'- 'Capote'- shows his thought on Perry by stating, "It's as if Perry and I grew up in the same house. And one day he stood up and went out the back door, while I went out the front". This shows how much Capote was able to see himself in Perry. This personal reflection gives Capote a tendency to lean towards his emotion and therefore he had created a well-polished character about Perry whereas Dick gets portrayed with faulty personality traits. Their deep emotional connection explains why in the novel, Perry gets described as a humane character who is able to draw the reader’s sympathy. Capote includes many details based on Perry's insight to create a character with good conscience, for example, "I know it is wrong. But at the time I never give any thought to whether it is right or wrong". To add depth to Perry's character, Capote includes many details about Perry's struggling childhood, for example, "I was very severely beaten by the cottage mistress, who had called me names and made fun of me in front of all the boys", and Perry's lack of affection from his parents through Perry's dad's letter for his children, "Mama told us not to talk to you". On the other hand, Dick's depiction about him in the novel gives him a ruthless and pedophiliac character, for example, "You're my baby girl. My little sweetheart”. Phil Tompkins, a reporter at Esquire magazine writes an article about Capote's alteration of Perry's diverting character because according to his interviews with the witnesses, Perry is not the nice guy who Capote has created. Again, Capote makes changes on his own will and this sacrifices his reader from the truth because of his personal preference about Perry. This changes the purpose of a non-fiction novel which is to deliver the truth to the reader.

Relating back to his 'orange' theory, Capote goes as far as indirectly impacting the outcome of the storyline to fit them into his 'orange'. There is prove of Capote’s intention to create his own story in his letter to Marie, Dewey’s wife, when he writes “Can you remember anything more about it (not that I mind inventing details, as you will see!)”. And as mentioned above, Capote is able to make connections with Perry; However, he sacrifices them by not providing a lawyer for both the murderers. He could have fought for his subjects but he knows that he would not have had an ending if they continue to live. As an author who proclaims himself to have created a new genre, he is not able to keep up with the standards by keeping himself as an outsider. Instead, Capote is indirectly invovled in the events of the storyline.

    As mentioned above, during the earlier stage of creating 'In Cold Blood', Capote claims that he will be the first to create a non-fiction novel. However, it seems like he crosses the border between 'immaculately factual' and partially factual; because he gets involved in the events and the outcomes of the case and he leans on his personal preferences to create what he thinks will fit thte best . In the end, Capote more or less defeats himself as he is not able to keep up with his own standard.
   
    Citation:
Weslie Jarvis. "Opinion: ‘Capote’ analyzes complexities". Fri Mar 31, 2006
Matthew Ricketson. "Truman Capote and the World He Made". Meanjin
Pati Hill. "Truman Capote, The Art of Fiction No. 17". The Paris Review
Truman Capote. In Cold Blood

Tuesday, 9 September 2014

OUTLINE

Thesis: Capote's character and his immaculate facts in his book 'In Cold Blood' are considered deceiving through various depictions of the making of the book. However, this aspect of his character and the book's details do not undermine nor subdue the moral and value of 'In Cold Blood'.

1st paragraph: The phrase 'Capote’s infractions also raise enduring questions about the slippery boundary between truth and fiction in narrative journalism, and the relationships that develop between a reporter and his source' alleges Capote for giving false information about the murder due to his interaction with the people involved in the murder. However this is only journalism encounter and it has nothing with the information that Capote got from his sources, it is just the matter of how he got it.

http://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/capotes-co-conspirators

2nd paragraph: ""If the case goes before a jury, I will request the jury, upon finding them guilty, to
sentence them to the death penalty. If the defendants waive right to jury trial and enter a
plea of guilty before the judge, I will request the judge to set the death penalty. This was
a matter I knew I would be called upon to decide, and my decision has not been arrived
at lightly. I feel that due to the violence of the crime and the apparent utter lack of
mercy shown the victims, the only way the public can be absolutely protected is to have
the death penalty set against these defendants. This is especially true since in Kansas
there is no such thing as life imprisonment without possibility of parole. Persons
sentenced to life imprisonment actually serve, on the average, less then fifteen years."

page 164 electronic copy

The death of Dick and Perry verses how much sympathy the reader has developed for them especially Perry show that what is right needs to be done no matter what the circumstance is.

Monday, 1 September 2014

Step two: Analyze the claim


Claim#3)


Capote’s journalism encounter to his sources reveals how he was granted the access to the interviews, investigation records and primary resources from the murder. 

In Bennett Miller’s film ‘Capote’ displays Capote as a deceiving man who seduced Perry and lied about his title of the book. He also persuaded the Kansas citizen ‘through a kind of velvet sorcery’. Though we are not sure about the source’s liability since 'sorcery' doesn't really exists. He even went as far as refusing to help find a lawyer for the criminals because unless they get executed he would not have had an ending. That action of refusal was no different from the title of his book In Cold Blood even though it was not his responsibility to find them a lawyer. Capote addressed Al Dewey in his letter as ‘Foxy’ and ‘Dearhearts’. In Cold Blood has got a lot of attention for its making. Two movies were based on its making because they portray the truth behind journalism. His journalism interaction with his sources portrays how he manipulated them in order to twist the fact so that they will fit into his story line. This explains how he was able to focus on certain characters and discarded the others altogether.

Friday, 29 August 2014

Claims and Arguments of the article' Capote's Co-conspirators - The New Yorker'

1) Capote’s scene of Harold Nye going to Hickock’s parents’ house to investigate after receiving the tip from prison was fictional.

As the Journal revealed a cache of the investigation records from Ron Nye, the son of Harold Nye, which has immense different account of what happened after the tip was received from prison. Harold Nye did not travel to the farmhouse ‘alone, at night, or under false pretenses’. In fact, the KBI acted 5 days later after they received the information and ‘three members of the K.B.I. made the trip. They did so during the day and spoke only with Hickock’s mother, and there was no ruse; they told her precisely why they were calling’.

2) Capote takes in account of some details and discards others. He pays attention on some character and ignores the others to arrange the information that best suits him. It was done so that his ‘immaculately factual’ novel becomes ‘engaging and suspenseful’.

His comments on actor Robert Blake who played Perry reveals the truth to his work, ‘Reflected reality is the essence of reality, the truer truth … all art is composed of selected detail, either imaginary or, as in In Cold Blood, a distillation of reality.’

3) In Cold Blood has got a lot of attention for its making. Two movies were based on its making because they portray the truth behind journalism.
Capote’s journalism encounter to his sources reveals how he was granted his access to his sources and how he manipulated his sources to bend the fact so they will fit into his story line.

In Bennett Miller’s film ‘Capote’ displays Capote as a deceiving man who seduced Perry and lied about his title of the book. He also persuaded the Kansas citizen ‘through a kind of velvet sorcery’. Though we are not sure about the source’s liability since 'sorcery' doesn't really exists. He even went as far as refusing to help find a lawyer for the criminals because unless they get executed he would not have had an ending. That action of refusal was no different from the title of his book In Cold Blood even though it was not his responsibility to find them a lawyer. Capote addressed Al Dewey in his letter as ‘Foxy’ and ‘Dearhearts’.



4) Capote’s subjects understand the importance of the end product of Capote’s going-to-get-published novel. Therefore Al Dewey chose to support Capote’s process of writing her novel. This not only cover up his erroneous initial believe that Dick and Perry were not the murderers, but he can further benefits from Capote’s flattering reflections about his investigation.  It is fair to say that Capote was indirectly hiding his mistake through being the co-conspirator.

Capote got to interview with Bobby Rupp because ‘because Al Dewey advised [him] to’. Al Dewey went as far as showing Capote the documents of the investigation which included Nancy’s diary.

.




Thursday, 21 August 2014

Read writer thing


· How would you describe yourself as a reader?
I am not a keen reader. However i have read books on my own before(not assigned books). I find books and novels boring. However i read a lot of articles. I like reading reviews about things that i like on the internet. Now that i am taking the global perspective class, i read a lot of articles about recent politics and i find them interesting. i would gladly read something short over some 500 pages book.

 
· How would you describe yourself as a writer?
I am a mediocre. i do not often make grammar mistakes and when i do i will know after re reading what i have written. I do not enjoy writing but i will do it when needed.
 
· What do you hope to get out of this class? What do you need help on the most as it relates to reading/writing for college-level classes?
I hope to know more about complex sentence structures and be able to use them fluently. Sometimes my points are not clearly shown because of my word choice so knowing the right word to use will do.
 
· What helps you learn? (In other words, do you prefer visuals, or lecture/discussion, or interactive?)
I learn from making mistakes so feedbacks will be helpful.
This writing diagnostic will help me to understand you as a writer, both as you see yourself and how I see you through the written word. I will take your questions, concerns and requests seriously as we continue through the semester. Thanks for your honesty!