Nam Le and William Faulkner both believe that writers have a responsibility to uphold universal truths and humanity through their work. Do you agree that writers have an obligation to do this?
Nam Le's story, Love and Honour and Pity and Pride and Compassion and Sacrifice, is an example of writing that is "worth writing about, worth the agony and the sweat" according to the idea presented by William Faulkner in his banquet speech. Faulkner claimed in his speech that it is a privilege for a write "to help man endure be lifting his heart, by reminding him of the courage and the honor and hope and pride and compassion and pity and sacrifice". Furthermore, if a writer forgets about the universal verities, then his writing is considered "ephemeral and doomed".
By adopting that Faulkner's idea into his story's title, Nam Le is admitting that it is a writer's obligation to represent man kind with universal truths and humanity. In the story, Nam Le reveals the process of him unfolding his way through the perpetual struggles between him and his father. In the end, he unravels the truth about his identity as a man, being that he was born not very long after the Vietnamese war, and most importantly, how that affects the perspective he holds about himself, his father and his country. In one scene, after reading a script written by Nam, his father says to him "You want their pity"; in the end of the story, his father burns the script that Nam Le has written about the War. Instead of getting mad at his father as usual, Nam Le now understands the value of writing that he is responsible for: his writing should not be an excuse about "defeats in which nobody loses of values, of victories" but "of the props, the pillars to help him endure and prevail", as mentioned by Faulkner in his speech that is referred to at the top.
Nevertheless, this idea of upholding these perpetual universal truths and verities seem to contradict the meaning of writing when it was first found by our ancestors since writing can be referred to as expression of language through letters or marks. Sumerian cuneiform is the first known writing form that dates back to 3300 BC. It simply contained symbols marked on clay and the expressions account a total of 1500 symbols themselves were limited. The writing was created to reflect their daily life activities, rituals events and warfare between different clans. Going even further back in time, stone men used to carved images of their tools, hunting animals and arcane symbols that represented their gods.*
Personally, writing should be able to get across a message to the reader and that message does not necessary need to include a significant depth of meaning to it in order to be worthwhile. A description or reflection of one's life, an intriguing event, or as simple as an object can be considered worthwhile. Although by lacking meaning from its content can result in little effect on the reader, a descriptive piece of writing or simply a diary can still be considered 'good' writing given that fact that reflecting and describing was once all there ever was in writing. William Faulkner can call a piece of writing "ephemeral" judging on its content, however, it will be unfair if he calls it "doomed" because if that piece of writing contains a message that the writer wants to get across to his reader, then it is definitely worthwhile.
*Early Forms of Writing: Cuneiform
https://web.cn.edu/kwheeler/documents/Cuneiform.pdf
No comments:
Post a Comment